Mystery Wine Madness ft. 6-Bottle Set Worth $1,375!

Earthy forest and mushroom flavors give this Anderson Valley Pinot Noir a rustic character, with touches of ripe olive and graham cracker. Smooth acidity and balanced tannins carry a hint of black tea into the finish.

92pt - Pekka Nuikki. Caymus’s 2023 Napa Cabernet layers blackberry, cassis and black cherry with mocha, vanilla, cocoa and baking spice. Plush dark fruit and velvety tannins shape its smooth, long finish.

96pt - James Suckling. Black and red currant meet graphite, dried flowers, herbs and wet stone. Fine tannins frame a generous palate and a long, mouthwatering finish.

94pt - Wine Enthusiast. Violet, tobacco, dried herbs and baking spice frame dark-fruit aromas. Black cherry, blackberry and plum fill a concentrated palate, with vanilla, fresh energy and a supple tannin structure.